If you’re looking for a place to eat in Key West, it can be hard to decide where to go! There are so many great places all within walking distance from each other.
In this post, we’ll give you the rundown on our 16 Best Restaurants In Key West Everyone Should Try and why they should be at the top of your list when planning your trip!
- 16 Best Restaurants In Key West Everyone Should Try
- Here are some of the most talked about restaurants in Key West:
- 1. Eaton Street Seafood Market
- 2. Hogfish Bar & Grill
- 3. Date & Thyme
- 4. Café Marquesa
- 5. Santiago’s Bodega
- 6. Glazed Donuts
- 7. El Siboney Restaurant
- 8. Garbo’s Grill
- 9. Banana Café
- 10. Nine One Five
- 11. First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery
- 12. The Café
- 13. Hot Tin Roof
- 14. Bagatelle
- 15. Latitudes
- 16. Blue Heaven
- Conclusion:
16 Best Restaurants In Key West Everyone Should Try
There are a multitude of restaurants in Key West, so visitors will have no trouble finding a place to eat. Many of the best restaurants in Key West are located on Duval Street, where locals and visitors alike love to eat.
In fact, other than the beaches in Key West, one of the most popular attractions is its restaurants. Foodies from all over come to taste the seafood dishes and international cuisine Key West has been known for since the 1800s.
And if you’re looking for a restaurant with a view , you’ll find those as well, along with romantic restaurants and those popular with the younger crowd who just want a place to dance .
Here are some of the most talked about restaurants in Key West:
1. Eaton Street Seafood Market
If you’re looking for some seafood, head over to Keyside! They have a wide selection of sandwiches and appetizers. You can get the best crab cake or fried fish combined with grilled lobster tail that’s sure not only delicious but healthy too – what more could anyone ask from their meal?
With a fresh seafood market in the middle of Key West, Florida you can be sure that your meal is as authentic and unique to this city as it would have been back when it. was first discovered.
Eaton Street Seafood Market has been a top choice among locals and visitors for over 15 years, so you know that this is one of the best restaurants in Key West!
2. Hogfish Bar & Grill
Hogfish Bar and Grill is the place to go for fresh seafood. The menu has all your favorite classics, but they’re not kidding around when they say “lively atmosphere.”
The Hogfish Bar and Grill is a true locals spot, tucked away in Safe Harbor. It avoids all of the pretension that can be found in more touristy areas like it’s sister restaurant just down the street from here,! Schooner Wharf.
This place is a favorite for its great food at reasonable prices, and it’s one of the best places to get your hands on some fresh seafood in Key West.
If you’re looking for a casual atmosphere with an unbeatable view, Hogfish Bar & Grill should be your go-to spot!
3. Date & Thyme
A quaint little cafe with an attached grocery store, Date & Thyme is the perfect place for organic foodies. They offer greasy fast food and fresh vegetarian dishes to suit4. any appetite – from sweet treats like brownies or cakes; hot plates filled with delicious noodles in soup; even rich ice cream!
Date & Thyme is a great place to get your hands on some healthy food while you’re in Key West, and it’s one of the best places for vegetarians.
Located right off Duval Street , Date & Thyme has been voted as having “the very best breakfast” by locals time after time!
So if you’re looking for the best breakfast in Key West, Date & Thyme is one of our favorites!
Date and Thyme Cafe was established to provide healthy food options where they are needed most. Serving home-cooked meals using fresh ingredients which are organic whenever possible. The menu will include many vegan, vegetarian and gluten free dishes as well as some meat options. Date and Thyme Cafe will have a small market to offer organic groceries, vitamins , supplements, gluten free flours and baking products along with some other healthy items for sale.
Date & Thyme is one of the best places in Key West where you can find vegetarian dishes!
4. Café Marquesa
A cozy, high-end hotel eatery that is famous for its genteel ambiance and innovative New American cooking.
The relaxed and welcoming atmosphere of Café Marquesa is the perfect spot to enjoy a fine meal with old friends, or make new ones while sipping on one our signature cocktails. Traditional Latin American dishes such as Cochinita Pibil (slow cooked pork) are served alongside masterful desserts like lemon chess pie that will have you coming back for seconds.!
Café Marquesa is one of the best places in Key West to enjoy a fine meal!
Located on Simonton Street, it has been voted as having “the very best breakfast” by locals time after time. If you’re looking for someplace with healthy and gourmet food, this should be your go-to spot!
Café Marquesa is a boutique hotel restaurant that offers innovative New American cuisine. The food here is excellent, and the atmosphere will make you feel right at home.
This place should definitely be on your list of restaurants to try while in Key West!
5. Santiago’s Bodega
The warm, comfortable atmosphere of Santiago’s Bodega is sure to please any palate. Whether you’re looking for a small plate or are craving something more indulgent like tapas and sangria paired with incredible drink specials; they’ve got it all at this welcoming tapas bar!
What’s not to love at Santiago’s Bodega? The laid-back atmosphere, affordable prices and mouth watering tapas will make you want more..
Located on Simonton Street , Santiago’s Bodega is one of the best places to get tapas in Key West.
The laid back atmosphere, affordable prices and excellent food make this place a must-visit while you’re here!
Santiago’s Bodega is an ideal spot if you are looking for a relaxed evening out. They offer affordable tapas and drinks, along with an excellent atmosphere that will make you feel right at home.
6. Glazed Donuts
Glazed Donuts is the spot to go if you’re looking for a good, old fashioned donut. They have all types of creative flavors that will make your mouth water just thinking about them! Not only do they serve up delicious pastries but also offer coffee drinks so there’s something here perfect no matter what mood strikes or how late it gets in town at night
The GLAZED DONUTS in Key West, Florida is a must-see for any doughnut lover. The store makes everything from scratch including fritter and cake varieties that are unique to this area of town!
What’s not to love about Glazed Donuts? The traditional donut flavors sure are tasty, but we’re also obsessed with their unique and creative options!
Located on Caroline Street , this place is a must-visit if you’re looking for the best doughnuts in Key West.
One of our favorite places in town, Glazed Donuts is a must-see for any doughnut lover! They have all sorts of unique flavors that will make your mouth water. Not to mention, their coffee drinks are perfect if you’re looking for something to wake you up in the morning or keep you going late at night.
7. El Siboney Restaurant
The food at El Siboney Restaurant is so authentic that it’s a family favorite in the region. With budget friendly prices, this Cuban institution will have you coming back for more!
El Siboney Restaurant – if you’re looking for a traditional Cuban dining experience, then look no further. The menu features home cooking and house made sangria in an inviting setting with family-friendly prices that will make your meal affordable without sacrificing quality or flavor!
What’s not to love about El Siboney Restaurant? The food is authentic and delicious, making it a family favorite in the region. Plus, the prices are budget-friendly without sacrificing quality or flavor.
This Cuban institution should definitely be on your list of restaurants to try while you’re in Key West!
El Siboney Restaurant is the perfect spot for those looking for a traditional Cuban dining experience.
Make sure to add this place to your list of restaurants to try while in Key West! You won’t regret it!
8. Garbo’s Grill
At Garbo’s Grill, they specialize in tacos and burritos. They have a wide variety of fillings for you to choose from such as beef brisket or cajun chicken breast among others that will satisfy anyone’s appetite!
Garbo’s Grill in Key West will feed your hungry soul with delicious takes on American cuisine! Try the Umami Burger or Kogi Dog and enjoy a relaxing meal. some of the best tacos and burritos in town.
At Garbo’s Grill, you can try anything from steak brisket to cajun chicken breast among other delicious options that are sure to satisfy your hunger!
Located on Simonton Street , this place is a must-visit if you want an American dining experience that will leave you stuffed and happy.
If you’re looking for a casual place to enjoy some delicious tacos and burritos, then Garbo’s Grill is the perfect spot for you! With options like beef brisket or cajun chicken breast, there’s something here for everyone to enjoy.
Make sure to add this spot to your list of places to visit while in Key West. You won’t regret it!
9. Banana Café
Banana Café is the place to go if you’re looking for something on the lighter side. It has a good selection of breakfast options, served in a low-key atmosphere that will make your day even better!
Banana Cafe Key West is a French Bistro with an alluring Caribbean twist. Served up daily for breakfast, lunch or dinner they take pride in their authentic Creole cuisine that will leave you wanting more!
Banana Café is the perfect place to go if you’re looking for something light and tasty. With a good selection of breakfast options, this café has everything you need to start your day off right.
The low-key atmosphere at Banana Café is perfect for those who want to relax and enjoy their meal without any distractions. Whether you’re looking for breakfast, lunch or dinner, you can expect to be wowed by Banana Café’s authentic Creole cuisine.
Add this café to your list of places to visit when in Key West and don’t forget about it! You won’t regret trying out their delicious options.
10. Nine One Five
Nine One Five is a tight-knit and relaxed venue for those who love to enjoy the flavors of various cultures. The patio out back provides both shade from summer sun or warmth when winter rolls around, while inside patrons can choose between American cuisine created with global flair!
Nine One Five has the highest food quality of any restaurant in its category, according to OpenTable diners’ reviews.. This intimate restaurant offers a variety of globally inspired cuisine and provides an elevated dining experience.
Nine One Five is the perfect place to visit if you’re looking for delicious global dishes served up in a relaxed setting with friendly staff!
Located right on Duval Street, this cozy spot features flavors from all over the world that will leave your stomach happy and content.
If you’re looking for a unique restaurant that offers cuisine from all over the world, then Nine One Five is the place for you! With an intimate setting and friendly staff, this spot is perfect for those who want to enjoy a relaxing meal.
11. First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery
First Flight Island Restaurant and Brewery is the perfect place to enjoy some American cuisine or sample their house brews while sipping on an Aviation-themed beer in a cool, aviation themed setting.
A local favorite, First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery is right in the heart of downtown Key West. With a slogan that promises “We’ll take you up on your best offer,” they have something to please every type of guest with their large menu and affordable prices.
First Flight Island Restaurant and Brewery is a cool spot with friendly staff that offers both American cuisine and their house brewed beer.
If you’re looking for an affordable place to eat with a large menu, First Flight Island Restaurant and Brewery should be at the top of your list. With aviation-themed decor and local favorite status, this spot is perfect for anyone who wants to have a good time.
12. The Café
The Café – A haven for locals and tourists alike, The Cafe serves up locally inspired seafood dishes alongside global cuisine. With a relaxed atmosphere complete with art on every wall of this chill spot you’ll be hard pressed not to enjoy yourself here!
The Cafe – The space is clean and airy, with a light atmosphere. You can grab an outdoor patio table or settle at one of their intimate indoor booth seating options to enjoy some vegan-friendly cuisine from around the world paired perfectly with craft beer & wine for when it’s time to get back out there!
The Café is a fantastic place to get away from it all. With an outdoor patio and live music on weekends, this bar has been my go-to for years now!
The Café is the perfect spot to enjoy some affordable food and beverages in a relaxed atmosphere with friendly staff! If you’re looking for an escape from reality, then this bar has everything you need to unwind after work or take your mind off stress during the weekend.
13. Hot Tin Roof
Hot Tin Roof offers a menu of small plates to choose from, with Latin American-style foods. Hot Tin Roof is a lounge and dining room featuring island style. Detailed teak woodwork, hand painted murals and ceiling, wild sculptures that bring whimsy to the space are just some highlights at Hot-Tin roof!
Hot Tin Roof is a restaurant with an elegance, water and sunset views that features food from around Florida. The menu has been highlighted for its “conch-fusion” style which combines traditional dishes to Latin American spices in order to create new ones.!
If you’re looking for a unique restaurant with an elegant atmosphere, then Hot Tin Roof is the place for you. With detailed woodwork and hand-painted murals, this spot offers a one-of-a-kind dining experience that you won’t find anywhere else.
14. Bagatelle
Bagatelle is located on the water and has an outdoor seating area where you can enjoy some seafood while watching people pass by. Bagatelle Island Restaurant is a historic restaurant in Key West, Florida just off Duval Street between Mallory Square.
The Bagatelles are known for their excellent seafood and romantic setting! When you’re looking for a Key West brunch experience, Bagatelle is your spot. The menu offers up all types of eggs including biscuits and gravy or chicken but there are so many more options to choose from!
Bagatelle is an unforgettable house that’s perfect for any occasion. You’ll feel at ease as soon as you walk in, and we’re sure our surroundings will make your stay a memorable one.! With a waterfront location and an outdoor seating area, Bagatelle is the perfect place to relax and enjoy some fresh seafood.
15. Latitudes
Latitudes is the perfect place for brunch. With so many scrumptious plates to choose from, like a crab cake Benedict or crispy fried French toast with powdered sugar on top and whip cream in between two Categories of breads sweetened just how you like it; there’s something sure fire at this restaurant that will make your taste buds smile all day long!
Latitudes is a Key West favorite for locals and visitors alike. This restaurant offers a wide variety of food, perfect for any palate. From crab cakes Benedict to crispy fried French toast, you’re sure to find something that satisfies your hunger here!
Latitudes has quickly become one of my favorite places to eat in Key West. With an extensive menu of delicious food items, this restaurant is perfect for anyone looking for a good meal. If you’re looking for somewhere to eat brunch, look no further than Latitudes!
16. Blue Heaven
The Blue Heaven restaurant is a Floridian-Caribbean landmark and key player in the world of cuisine. The food here is iconic for its freshness, taste quality as well as presentation; it’s also famous because you can enjoy them at their beachfront location or inside where it has an airy vibe thanks to all those natural light streaming through windows that make up part of this unique place!
The food at Ricky’s Blue Heaven is mouthwatering. You can enjoy a delicious breakfast, lunch or dinner in their Caribbean-themed restaurant and be transported to an authentic Key West with every bite you take!
At the iconic Blue Heaven restaurant in Key West, they are famous for their southern and Caribbean style food. The menu is packed full of interesting options such as burritos with blueberry sauce or Jamaican curry chicken sandwich- both yummy! You’ll also find some really great desserts like key lime pie (it’s made fresh every day) or a chocolate souffle. If you’re visiting Key West, don’t miss out on this place!
Conclusion:
There are plenty of delicious restaurants in Key West for you to try. Whether you’re looking for seafood, brunch, or a unique experience, there’s something sure to satisfy your appetite! Be sure to check out Bagatelle, Latitudes, Blue Heaven, and Hot Tin Roof while you’re in town. You won’t regret it!
